Used Toyota Highlander for Sale in Indianapolis, IN

If you are looking for the benefits of an SUV for your growing Fishers family at an attainable price, don’t miss the used Toyota Highlanders available at O'Brien Toyota. Explore our available models to find seating for up to eight and a variety of other features you are sure to love.

• Contact Info

• First Name*
• Last Name*
• Phone
• Email*
• Contact Preference?*
  • Phone
  • Email
• Zip Code*

• What Are You Looking For?

• Type*
  • New
  • Used
• Year*
  20252024202320222021202020192018
• Mileage (Max)*
  50001000015000200002500030000400005000060000700008000090000100000150000Any
• Price (Max)*
  Any$200000$150000$120000$100000$90000$80000$70000$60000$50000$40000$30000$25000$20000$15000$10000$5000
• Make*
• Model*
• Trim*
• Color*
• Transmission*
  • Automatic
  • Manual
• Message

• By submitting this form, you agree to be contacted with information regarding the vehicle you are searching for.

Referral ID

By submitting this form, you authorize O'Brien Toyota to contact you by texts, calls and email.

Your Email

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Toyota Highlander Highlights

Search our inventory of used Toyota Highlanders and you can find models with features like:

• 83.7 cubic feet of cargo space
• Head-turning towing capabilities
• 60/40 split-seat third-row seating that can both recline and fold flat
• The Toyota Safety Sense™ suite of safety features including Dynamic Radar Cruise Control (DRCC), Lane Departure Alert (LDA), and more
• Entune infotainment with hands-free phone connectivity, music streaming, and available navigation

Why Choose O'Brien Toyota?

O'Brien Toyota is the best place to come when you want to find a used Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis. That’s because no one else in the area has as wide a selection of available vehicles as we do. When you want to find a used Toyota Highlander for sale in Indianapolis, we make it easy to locate one that fits your budget and has all the features you need. Many of our available stock are rated at 20 mpg or higher, including our used Toyota Highlander hybrids.

We make it easy to buy a used Toyota Highlander, thanks to our streamlined online credit application process and wide range of financing options. We’ll also offer you top dollar for your trade-in if you have one. Even after you drive off the lot, we continue to support you with our service center and technicians, who know Toyota vehicles better than just about anyone else in the area. As a family-owned business that has served the area for a long time, we’re dedicated to treating our customers fairly and doing right by them in everything we do. If you’re not sure a Highlander is right for you, click here to see our other used vehicles.

When browsing our inventory, our online monthly payment calculator can help you zero in on a Highlander that will match both your budget and needs. Once you have settled on a model, contact us at O'Brien Toyota to schedule your test drive. You can even apply for financing online before making the trip and we can have options waiting when you arrive! If buying isn’t the best option for you, be sure to check out our available Toyota lease deals!