Check Availability

    • By submitting this form, you authorize O'Brien Toyota to contact you by texts, calls and email.
    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

      Drive a Reliable and Affordable Used Car from O'Brien Toyota!

      If you’re looking for where to buy a good used car cheap in the Indianapolis area, O'Brien Toyota has a selection of reliable used cars under $10,000, and we carry cars under $5,000, too! We offer a wide range of varied makes and models can fit into just about any budget. Whether you’re looking for a small car for a fuel efficient commute, a midsize sedan with leather seats for family road trips, or your focus is on having enough cargo space for the job, you’ll find it on our lot!

      Don’t risk getting stranded by going to just any cheap used car dealership around Fishers! When you’re buying a car, you should be able to trust the dealership, which is why we provide a free CarFax vehicle history report and our service department has thoroughly inspected each and every car on our lot. Visit us at your leisure to pursue our affordable Toyota models, to see our Toyota lease deals if buying isn’t right for you, then stop by and take a test drive; our staff will be happy to show you our variety of cheap used cars for sale in Indianapolis.

      O'Brien Toyota 39.8039835, -86.0470617.