Date Night in Indianapolis: Restaurants and Things to Do

Mama Carollas courtesy of her website

There are always tons of great things to do in Indianapolis, from the Indy Motor Speedway to the Indianapolis Museum of Art, there, but this city also has some of the best culinary experiences in the entire Midwest! These Indianapolis restaurants will blow you away with their innovative flavors, fresh ingredients, and impeccable service. If you’re planning your next date night in Indianapolis, don’t miss out on the hottest eateries in the area, as selected by O'Brien Toyota.

Hotels in Downtown Indy Other Fun in Indy

Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant

Are you in the mood for Italian? Let Mama Carolla take care of you and your appetite for the night with a trip to this gorgeous Broad Ripple bungalow turned bistro! This gorgeous restaurant has a lovely atmosphere with cozy tables in the dining room and a wonderful outdoor patio that overlooks a nearby trail. Traditional Italian fare like the lasagna and bolognese are hearty options for a main course, but you should be sure to save room for a couple’s desert! Try the Holly’s Homemade Ricotta Cake.

Harry and Izzy’s

A cousin to the classic St. Elmo Steak House, Harry and Izzy’s is a new and fresh option for the Indianapolis foodie. The wine selection is astounding, including hundreds of different bottles from the in-house wine cellar, and the boldly-styled bar is a great place to pick up a perfectly blended cocktail. But the real star of the show is the food. Cracked peppercorn New York Strip and South African Lobster Tail are perfect for a special occasion, but Harry and Izzy’s also has more casual fare like shrimp po boy sliders and Tuscan thin crust pizza.


The award-winning Bluebeard was named after a classic Kurt Vonnegut novel, which makes it a great spot for literary aficionados. The venue is an incredible renovated warehouse from the 1920s, transformed into a modern space with an ever-changing menu composed of local ingredients. Start with the homemade bread with anchovy butter and roasted garlic oil, or try a side of wings with cilantro lime crema and Korean barbecue sauce. Then get ready for sensational plates like steak frites with truffle aioli, duck breast tartine with ratatouille, or salmon with brown butter hollandaise!

Plan Your Next Date Night Today!

If you’re planning to visit some of the best places to eat in Indianapolis, why not make a night of it? Check out the best parks in Indianapolis, the best ice cream in Indianapolis, or the best hotels in downtown Indianapolis that put you close to all the best attractions and restaurants in the area. Contact us at O'Brien Toyota today for more recommendations!

More from O'Brien Toyota

  • How Much Can a Toyota RAV4 Tow?

    The 2020 Toyota RAV4 towing capacity is 3,500 pounds when properly equipped, allowing you to tow a small trailer or boat around the Fishers area. The advanced Adventure trim allows for up to 3,500 pounds of towing power with a payload capacity of up to 1,090 pounds. The 2020 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid LE has a…

  • 2020 Toyota Tacoma MPG

    Fishers drivers recognize the Tacoma as a historically substantial truck in the 1990s and early 2000s before its departure in 2004. Since its return in 2015, the Tacoma has been a dominant fixture among its competition, and for good reason. From a sleek design, incredible features, and the latest technology, the Toyota Tacoma is a…

  • What are the 2020 Toyota RAV4 Trim Levels?

    The 2020 Toyota RAV4 configurations range in price starting at $25,850 MSRP* to $35,180 MSRP*, making the new Toyota RAV4 an excellent SUV for families and new drivers. Choose one of the RAV4 configurations that have the features that you need to enhance your commute to New Palestine without going outside of your budget. What’s better…

  • How to Reset the Maintenance Light on a Toyota Corolla

    Once you have finished your recommended maintenance tasks on your Toyota Corolla, you may notice that your maintenance light is still on. If you’re looking to turn off the Toyota maintenance light, the Toyota Corolla makes it easy to accomplish. Follow the easy steps provided by O'Brien Toyota, or visit our Indianapolis service center for additional…

  • What are the Toyota Prius Models?

    The Toyota Prius family is growing, with three hybrid models including a Prius plug-in hybrid option. It’s a smart pick for Fishers drivers looking for an eco-friendly and wallet-friendly hatchback. Compare Prius models below, then contact us for a test drive at O'Brien Toyota to take the next step toward an amazing fuel economy.  View Inventory…

  • 2019 Toyota Tacoma Parts

    If you want genuine OEM 2019 Toyota Tacoma accessories and parts, the O'Brien Toyota parts department should be your first visit. We offer an extensive inventory of high-quality, genuine OEM auto parts that will fit your Tacoma pickup truck. Tacoma parts range from exterior steps to towing accessories. Learn more by visiting O'Brien Toyota near Fishers. View…

Image above courtesy of